The Ultimate Showdown: Rock Lobster vs Maine Lobster Revealed!

Are you a seafood enthusiast who loves indulging in lobsters? Have you ever wondered about the differences between Maine lobsters and rock lobsters? Do you want to know which is better for your next seafood dinner party?

In this blog post, we will uncover the ultimate showdown between Maine lobsters and rock lobsters, revealing the pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.

Maine lobsters’ delicate consistency and sweet flavor are unmatched, while rock lobsters have a subtle flavor that may appeal to only some. Maine lobsters have more enormous claws and tender meat, while rock lobsters have firmer flesh due to living in warm waters. Knowing these differences can help you decide which one to choose for your next seafood meal.

In the following sections, we will delve deeper into Maine and rock lobsters’ taste, texture, and cooking methods to provide extensive information to satisfy your seafood appetite.

Additionally, we will explore the nutritional value, availability, and pricing differences between these two types of lobsters. So, let’s dive in and discover the ultimate showdown between Maine lobsters and rock lobsters!

The Differences Between Maine Lobsters and Rock Lobsters

The main difference between Maine and rock lobsters is all in the claws! Maine lobsters boast larger nails, and the meat inside is exceptionally tender. Meanwhile, rock lobsters have larger antennas, but their feet are nonexistent. Additionally, the heart of rock lobsters is typically drier, coarser, and less sweet than Maine lobsters. When it comes down to it, Maine lobster meat is just more delicate overall.

Maine lobsters and rock lobsters also differ in habitat and appearance. Maine lobsters are typically found in the cold, rocky waters of the Atlantic Ocean, and they have a distinct red color with black-tipped claws. On the other hand, rock lobsters are more commonly found in warmer waters and have a spiny appearance with a greenish-brown color. In terms of taste, Maine lobsters are known for their succulent, buttery flavor, while rock lobsters have more of a mild, slightly sweet taste.

When it comes to cooking, these lobster varieties also differ slightly. Maine lobsters are best served, with just a bit of butter to accentuate their natural flavor. On the other hand, rock lobsters are often used in more elaborate dishes, as their meat has a firmer texture that can hold up to bolder flavors. 

Overall, the main difference between Maine lobsters and rock lobsters is that Maine lobsters are more delicate and tender, while rock lobsters are heartier and better suited for bolder dishes.

The Taste and Texture of Maine Lobsters

Maine Lobster
Maine lobster

When it comes to taste and texture, Maine lobsters reign supreme. Known for its buttery and sweet flavor, Maine lobster meat has a tender, meaty, and satisfying texture. And although lobster meat tastes similar to crab, it’s sweeter, cleaner, and lighter. No wonder they’re considered the king of all crustaceans and command the highest price.

But let’s get into the nitty-gritty of what makes Maine lobsters so delectable. Here are some additional details on their taste and texture:

  • Flavor: Maine lobsters have a unique flavor thanks to their diet, which usually consists of fish, crustaceans, and mollusks. This diet gives them a slightly briny taste with a subtle sweetness that lingers on the palate. And because Maine lobsters are typically cooked live, their flavor is as fresh as it gets.
  • Texture: The meat of a lobster tail has a firm, chewy texture from the high amount of protein. But don’t mistake “chewy” for tough – when cooked properly, the surface is incredibly tender and meaty. And because Maine lobsters have large claws, their meat is succulent, with a satisfying snap when you bite into it.
  • Color: Maine lobster meat is typically a bright, vibrant white that contrasts beautifully with the bright red of their shells. This color indicates the meat’s freshness and gives Maine lobsters a visual appeal that’s hard to resist.

Cooking Methods for Maine Lobsters

Want to know how to cook Maine lobsters? There are a variety of ways to prepare these succulent crustaceans. Here are some simple tips and tricks that will make your lobster dinner a hit:


Boiling is the most common way to cook lobsters. Fill a large pot with salt water and bring it to a boil. Then, add the lobsters to the pot and cook for about 8-12 minutes, depending on the size. The water should cover the lobsters entirely. Boiling lobsters is an easy and quick way to cook them, and the meat will be tender and succulent.


Steaming is an alternative method to boiling. You will need a large pot with a steamer insert. Fill the pot with water, bring it to a boil, then add the steamer basket with the lobsters inside. Cover the pot tightly and steam for about 14-16 minutes. Steaming is an excellent option for those who want to avoid the messy process of boiling lobsters.


Grilling lobsters is a little more complicated than boiling or steaming, but it yields delicious results. To grill lobsters, split them in half, season them with butter or herbs, and then grill them for about 5-7 minutes.


If you want to avoid twitching or movement of the lobsters, you can try hypnotizing them. This technique involves placing the lobster on its back and stroking its head until it becomes motionless. Then, you can cook it as desired.

Slow Heating:

Another way to “put lobsters to sleep” before cooking is to immerse them in cold water and slowly heat it until they are lethargic. This method can take up to 45 minutes, but it will ensure that the lobsters will not move during cooking.

Availability and Pricing of Maine Lobsters

Maine lobsters are easily accessible through online and seafood markets. You can get your hands on both live lobsters and lobster meat. The live Maine lobsters are available online, with prices ranging from $49.95 for 1.5 pounds to $144.00 for 5-6 pounds.

On the other hand, the cost of Maine lobster meat per pound ranges from $35 to $120, depending on the company you buy from.

Now let’s dive deeper into the availability and prices of Maine lobsters. Here’s a breakdown of some key points to consider:

  • Availability of Maine Lobsters: Maine lobsters are usually available all year round, but the price and availability might fluctuate based on the season. Prices tend to increase when lobster is in high order in the summer months. During the winter, the demand for lobster drops, making it easier to find lobsters for lower prices.
  • Buying Live Lobsters: If you’re looking to buy live Maine lobsters, choosing a reputable seller is essential. Many online seafood markets sell live lobsters shipped overnight to your doorstep. It’s important to note that live lobsters must be cooked soon after they arrive to ensure ultimate freshness.
  • Pricing of Maine Lobsters: The price of Maine lobsters varies based on factors like season, availability, and demand. In 2021, the price lobstermen were getting at the dock was historically high, with fishermen in Maine receiving roughly $8.00 per pound. This price increase was due to many factors, including the pandemic, which has caused disruptions in the lobster supply chain.
  • Maine Lobster Meat: If you prefer lobster meat, you can purchase it online or at local seafood markets. The price of lobster meat usually ranges from $35 to $120 per pound, depending on the supplier, and lobster meat can be used in various dishes, such as lobster rolls or pasta dishes.

The Taste and Texture of Rock Lobsters

Rock Lobster
Rock Lobster

The taste and texture of rock lobsters can be quite different from their Maine lobster counterparts. While the meat has a similar meaty texture, it tends to be coarser and drier. And don’t expect the sweetness of a Maine lobster – rock lobsters have a saltier, fishier taste which lends itself well to bolder sauces and seasonings.

The warm water where rock lobsters reside also contributes to their tough texture. But despite its toughness, the meat is still firm and has a slight chewiness that some lobster enthusiasts appreciate. Its richer flavor is often compared to shrimp’s but with better consistency.

When cooked, it’s important to remember that rock lobsters can become quite challenging if overdone. Using a gentler cooking method like poaching or grilling is recommended to bring out the best texture and flavor. And if you’re looking for a way to highlight the taste of the meat, many chefs recommend simple preparations like butter or lemon to let the lobster’s natural flavor shine.

Rock lobsters may not be as well-known as their Maine cousins, but they offer unique flavors and textures worth exploring. Whether you prefer a little bit of sweetness or a bolder taste, there’s no doubt that these lobsters are a delicious addition to any seafood lover’s menu.

Cooking Methods for Rock Lobsters

There are several methods you can use to prepare these succulent crustaceans. Boiling and steaming work well for whole rock lobsters, while roasting and grilling is perfect for lobster tails. Keep reading to learn more!

Boiling and Steaming

Whole rock lobsters take best to boiling or steaming. To cook rock lobsters, bring a large pot of salted water to a boil and add the lobsters. The cooking time for rock lobsters depends on their weight. For example, 400g to 600g rock lobster takes 8-10 minutes to cook, while 800g to 1kg takes 12-15 minutes and a further minute for each additional 100g.

Barbecuing and Grilling

For a different take on your rock lobster dish, try barbecuing or grilling. These methods work well for lobster tails. Brush the lobster with butter, garlic, and lemon juice, and place the flesh on a hot grill. Cook the seats for 6-8 minutes or until the meat is opaque and cooked through.


Roasted rock lobster tails can be made by cutting through the top shell of a lobster tail and roasting it in a shallow-sided baking dish lined with parchment paper. Simply brush the inside of the bottom with some butter, garlic, and lemon juice and roast it in the oven for 8-10 minutes. Burning the lobster tails this way results in a succulent and tender flavor.

Now you know several methods to cook rock lobsters to perfection. Whether you choose to boil, steam, barbecue, grill, or roast your lobsters, the key is to cook them until the flesh is opaque and cooked through. Enjoy your delicious lobster dish!

Availability and Pricing of Rock Lobsters

Rock lobsters are readily available online and in seafood markets, ensuring that lobster enthusiasts can relish the delicacy whenever they crave it. Prices for rock lobsters are highly dependent on the weight, location, and the individual company selling them.

Alibaba offers reasonably priced frozen rock lobsters, while Ferguson Australia offers fresh whole, cooked rock lobsters from $42.00 to $256.00. 

Keys Fisheries offer spiny lobster tails at $38.95 per pound, and Bradley’s Fish sells whole raw rock lobsters weighing 600-800g for £35.00. The average beach price for Western Rock Lobsters currently ranges between $40 – $45/kg.

While rock lobsters might be the less well-known of the two, it is certainly worth trying them out. They have a distinct flavor profile, different from Maine lobsters, which gives them their unique sweet, succulent taste. Additionally, rock lobsters have various health benefits, including high protein content and a low-fat ratio, making them a favorite among seafood lovers.

The availability of rock lobsters is vast, with their habitats covering many coastal regions worldwide. They can be found on the East and West coasts of America, Europe, Australia, and New Zealand. Being so widely distributed, rock lobsters are easily accessible to all those who want to try them out.

Pricing for rock lobsters ranges widely, and it is essential to check out different companies to determine the best rates. Although fresh lobsters might seem expensive than frozen ones, they are worth the splurge as they have a better taste and texture. M

oreover, pricing often varies by location and season, with specific times of the year being more abundant than others. Therefore keeping an eye on different companies and their pricing structures can ensure you secure the best deal.

Which One to Choose: Maine Lobster or Rock Lobster?

If you’re wondering which type of lobster to choose, the answer is simple – Maine lobster. Here’s why:

  • Maine lobsters have a clean, sweet taste, which is widely considered superior to the briny taste of rock lobsters.
  • Their meat is more tender, thanks to their enormous claws containing succulent beef.
  • In contrast, rock lobsters typically have dry and coarser meat, making them less appealing to many.

But let’s dive into the topic more deeply to help you make a better-informed decision.

Maine Lobster

Maine lobsters are the most popular lobster variety in the US, and here’s why:

  • They are mainly caught in colder water, such as the North Atlantic, which gives them their distinctive meat flavor.
  • Maine lobsters’ claws are more enormous, contain more meat, and are softer than rock lobsters’ claws.
  • They also have a higher fat content than rock lobsters. This fat gives the meat a sweeter and richer flavor.

Rock Lobster

Rock lobsters are primarily found in warm waters like the Caribbean, the Mediterranean, and Australia. Here’s what you need to know about them:

  • They have a brinier taste than Maine lobsters because they dwell in warmer waters.
  • Rock lobsters are generally more undersized, have thinner shells, and lack large claws but use long antennae to catch food.
  • Although they are still tasty, their meat is generally dryer and coarser than Maine lobsters.

So, to summarize, if you prefer clean, delicate, and sweet lobster meat, go for the Maine lobster. But if the briny taste of rock lobsters appeals to you, then go for it. Ultimately, it comes down to your taste preferences, but now you know the facts to help you make an informed choice.

Share your love
Bill Kalkumnerd
Bill Kalkumnerd

I am Bill, I am the Owner of HappySpicyHour, a website devoted to spicy food lovers like me. Ramen and Som-tum (Papaya Salad) are two of my favorite spicy dishes. Spicy food is more than a passion for me - it's my life! For more information about this site Click

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *